Amazon Handmade vs Etsy: Which Is Best for Your Handmade Business?
If you’re an artisan or crafter looking to sell your handmade goods online, the choice of platform can make or break your business. Two of the biggest names in this space are Amazon Handmade and Etsy, each offering unique advantages and challenges. For a detailed comparison, check out this comprehensive amazon handmade vs etsy breakdown, but here’s an engaging summary to help you decide which marketplace fits your brand and goals.
The Marketplace Vibes: Etsy’s Handmade Haven
Etsy has long been the go-to marketplace for creative entrepreneurs. It’s a community that thrives on individuality, vintage charm, and the handmade ethos. Sellers on Etsy benefit from a platform that’s built exclusively for crafters, artists, and collectors, which means customers expect and actively seek out unique, handcrafted products.
One of Etsy’s standout features is its user-friendly setup and lower barrier to entry. It’s relatively easy to start selling, with minimal upfront costs—just a $0.20 listing fee per item and a 6.5% transaction fee. Etsy’s audience is already tuned in to handmade and custom items, making it a natural fit for artisans who want to build a brand around creativity and personal touch.
Amazon Handmade: The Giant’s Handcrafted Corner
Amazon Handmade, on the other hand, brings the power of Amazon’s vast infrastructure and customer base to handcrafted sellers. However, it’s not just any seller who can jump in; Amazon vets its artisans to ensure quality and authenticity, which adds a layer of exclusivity.
The biggest draw here is access to Amazon’s millions of shoppers and its renowned fulfillment network. For sellers who want to scale quickly and tap into an enormous audience, Amazon Handmade is hard to beat. The fee structure is different too—there’s no per-listing fee, but a 15% referral fee applies on sales. Plus, if you use Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), you can offer Prime shipping, which can be a game-changer for customer satisfaction and repeat business.
Seller Experience and Brand Identity
Etsy sellers often highlight the platform’s community feel and the ability to personalize their shops with branding elements. This helps artisans connect directly with customers who appreciate the story behind each creation. Etsy also supports customization and made-to-order items easily, which appeals to buyers looking for something truly unique.
Amazon Handmade’s seller interface is more streamlined but less customizable, designed to integrate with Amazon’s broader ecosystem. This means less control over your storefront’s “look and feel,” but more exposure to a wider, diverse audience who trust Amazon’s reliability and convenience.
Who Wins on Fees and Profit Margins?
Cost is always a critical factor. Etsy’s fees are generally lower, which can be beneficial for sellers with lower price points or those just testing the waters. Amazon Handmade’s higher referral fee can eat into margins, but the volume and potential for bigger sales might offset that.
Keep in mind that Amazon Handmade requires approval to join, which can add time before you start selling. Etsy’s open platform means you can jump in immediately and start listing your products.
Marketing and Traffic: Where Do Customers Come From?
On Etsy, a lot of traffic comes organically through the platform’s search engine and community features. Sellers often supplement this with social media marketing and email campaigns to drive traffic to their shops.
With Amazon Handmade, the traffic is huge but less targeted specifically for handmade goods. However, the trust factor and convenience of Amazon’s checkout process can lead to higher conversion rates. Plus, Amazon’s advertising tools provide powerful ways to promote your listings within the marketplace.
Final Thoughts and Recommendations
Choosing between Amazon Handmade and Etsy isn’t about picking a “better” platform—it’s about aligning your business needs with the platform’s strengths.
- Choose Etsy if: You want to cultivate a brand around handmade craftsmanship, enjoy a community-driven marketplace, and prefer lower upfront costs. Etsy is ideal for smaller shops, custom orders, and sellers who want to tell a story behind their products.
- Choose Amazon Handmade if: You’re ready to scale quickly, want access to a massive audience, and can handle the higher fees in exchange for Amazon’s infrastructure and fulfillment capabilities. It’s also a great option if you want to leverage Prime shipping and Amazon’s trusted checkout.
For many artisans, a hybrid approach might work best—starting on Etsy to build brand presence and customer relationships, then expanding to Amazon Handmade to tap into larger volume sales. Either way, understanding the nuances of each platform will help you maximize your handmade business’s potential.
To dive deeper into the specifics, including fee breakdowns and seller experiences, don’t miss the full comparison at amazon handmade vs etsy.
Checkout ProductScope AI’s Studio (and get 200 free studio credits)